The End of the Phone Book?

by John Lusk on June 19, 2009

OK. Back in January I wrote about why people really don’t need paper phone books and how continuing to print these phone books is a massive drain on the environment.  Well, it looks as if AT&T is under the same impression and is working tirelessly to rid themselves of the phone book printing burden.

Earlier in the year, AT&T convinced Ohio state regulators to allow them not to print and distribute phone books. (note: for those of you who don’t know, the telephone companies have a legal obligation to print and distribute paper phone books.  Seriously!).  Just this past week, AT&T was successful in convincing the Florida Public Service Commission to do the same thing, all in the name of saving the environment and making our country a greener place.

Now, to be fair, AT&T’s rationale for ending the distribution of phone books isn’t entirely altruistic.  These things cost a ton of money to print and distribute, with some analysts pegging the total costs in the billions of $$$.  So, money is involved and I’m taking a wild guess that most consumers won’t see the benefit of AT&T’s cost savings.  But still, AT&T’s momentum again begs the question.  Why in the world do we need paper phone books?

Let me launch into my personal plug for WhitePages to help answer that question. Three more reasons why you don’t need phone books:

  • WhitePages service covers over 90% of the US Adult population and includes more than 200M individuals. We just about have every US resident available to people online. If you have access to the internet, you don’t need a phone book.
  • We’ve been expanding our services into cell phones. You can now access our information on all iPhone, Android and BlackBerry phones. Actually, any phone that can access the internet can access our services.
  • The paper phone books are all land-line based. That is, they don’t include cell phone numbers or email addresses. With WhitePages Connectory services, not only can you privately add your own listing, but you can find people who otherwise wouldn’t be reachable through that old phone book

And it’s not like people aren’t already using WhitePages. In 2008, our customers performed over 2B searches on WhitePages. That’s the equivalent of $3B in savings had they tried to access that information via 411 services that charge $1.50/call (caveat: this is just a wild guess. Don’t read too much into this number…I’m just trying to make a point).

And for those of you who are wondering what happens to those individuals who are in remote locations and don’t have access to the internet or to a computer, AT&T has proposed a solution. Why not allow those customers to continue to opt-in to receiving the paper phone book? That way, those who absolutely need a paper phone book can continue to receive them but AT&T doesn’t incur the costs of mass-printing and distribution.

This movement is sure to play out over the coming years, but it sure seems that a transformation of traditionally paper-based businesses is among us (think newspapers, phone books, financial statements).

What else is out there?

John

Share

{ 10 comments… read them below or add one }

John Harvey Irwin June 29, 2009 at 2:17 pm

John,

Thanks for your comment on my blog post last week. Today I posted an update on my blog from last week after receiving an interesting email from Phil Wojcik, Director for the Yellow Pages Do Not Distribute website.

http://johnharveyirwin.wordpress.com/2009/06/29/revealing-update-on-dexs-phone-directory-dumping/

Clearly this is a very complex issue. Yet it’s great to know Whitepages and others are working hard to raise consumer awareness and fighting the good fight.

Keep it up! John Harvey Irwin

Reply

Buchholz July 2, 2009 at 7:56 am

John,
I don’t suppose you will post this comment. But I just want to say, I used White Pages to find a phone number. The person I was looking for came up, but w/o the phone number. Then I got a message that in order to get the number, I had to sign up and that is was free.

So I signed up to be a member of your site and then went back into search… And to my shock.. GOT A MESSAGE… NO RECORD WAS FOUND ???? and I should use a sponser web site, which of course, probably would be a fee.

What a gimmick..

Reply

Karen July 16, 2009 at 9:09 am

The new Bing maps are GARBAGE. I use zaba search now.

Reply

Sunnie July 17, 2009 at 1:52 pm

Your new site stinks. It is NOT user friendly. When I signed up to become a member just to find a phone number you never called me to complete the sigh up . Then I was asked to take a survey, enter a contest, and buy contact lenses. Never Never got a phone number. Don’t stop printing the white pages when you can’t get this right! Who ever thought of this is twisted

Reply

yadith July 18, 2009 at 11:11 pm

I agree when you said that phone books are causing a great impact in our environment, i do believe that electronic white pages (or yellow pages as in our case) is useful and efficient way to find out dates about people , but i have to say that it would be better if all phone companies work on update those pages ….
yadi

Reply

BT July 21, 2009 at 1:06 pm

Believe it or not, some people are not internet-savvy – nor do they want to give out personal information (like having to become a “member” for free info) just to obtain someone’s telephone number. This used to be my favorite phone number site, because it was quick and easy. Not the case anymore. Keep it simple. Not everything has to be “new and improved!”

Reply

John Lusk July 6, 2009 at 9:03 am

Buckholz,

WhitePages only requires a user to become a member when that user is accessing one of our Exclusive listings. So, if you were searching for somebody and we have them in our database, but they’re an exclusive listings, we ask that you sign up, for free. to become a Member.

Not too sure what happened in your case, but I can assure you that we’re not charging users to view listings.

On a side note, if you have any thoughts on this post regarding Phone Books and their potential environmental impact, please feel free to comment.

John

Reply

John Lusk July 19, 2009 at 8:11 pm

Sunnie,

I’m really sorry that WhitePages didn’t meet your needs. If you joined WhitePages, you would have received either a text message to your phone or an email asking you to verify your information. Unfortunately, we don’t actually call members in order to verify their information.

And don’t worry, we don’t want the phone book to go away. We just want to do whatever we can to encourage people to save trees and save $$$ on recycling costs.

Again, sorry that you didn’t have a good experience with WhitePages.

John

Reply

John Lusk July 19, 2009 at 8:16 pm

Thanks for the comment Yadith. I do agree that the phone companies can do a better job of updating their information. They’ll never be totally accurate, however, given that printing and distributing a phone book takes time (hence the reason most phone companies only deliver phone books 1-2x per year).

WhitePages will continue to deliver the most accurate contact information though, so you’ll always have the online option!

John

Reply

John Lusk July 20, 2009 at 10:56 am

Sunnie,

Just did some further digging on your post. It’s possible that our verification email is going to your spam email box – you might want to check that this is not the case. If you’re still having problems, visit our help center: http://www.whitepages.com/help , select “WhitePages account” and at the bottom, there is a contact us link that you can use to contact our customer service group. Sorry for the inconvenience.

John

Reply

Leave a Comment

Previous post:

Next post: